Sunday, November 07, 2010

Joe Schwarz Should Run for Senate

The 2012 campaign is already underway. By now the media has taken its attention away from the midterms and is gearing up for a heated reelection campaign for President Obama. Obama will have to lay out his agenda in the coming months as he delivers his State of the Union address with the hopes of turning around the economy and the situation in Afghanistan.

Republicans will offer an array of Presidential hopefuls, each with their own set of bona fides, hoping to corral the entire party behind him (or her). Voters will get reacquainted with the likes of Mitt Romney, Sarah Palin, and Mike Huckabee, while others will be introduced to the likes of Tim Pawlenty.

We in Michigan will have a Senate election as Senator Debbie Stabenow is up for reelection. Stabenow won a close race in 2000 over incumbent Spencer Abraham, and won reelection in 2006 over Oakland County Sheriff Mike Bouchard. Stabenow was largely credited for leading the ticket, despite the fact that it was Gov. Jennifer Granholm whose name was at the top of the ticket.

Stabenow is very popular among Democrats, and among voters across the state. At one time, she was the third-ranking Democrat in the Senate after Dick Durbin, the Minority Whip, and Harry Reid, the Democratic Leader. Virtually no Republican in the state has a shot at unseating her.

Except Joe Schwarz.

Dr. Joe Schwarz is a former Congressman who served Michigan's 7th Congressional District from 2005-2007. Schwarz's resume makes Stabenow's seem rather plain. Don't get me wrong, Stabenow is no slouch. She earned her bachelor's from Michigan State, and an MSW from MSU (she was a grad student when she won her first elected office).

Whereas as Stabenow went from being an Ingham County Commissioner to State Representative, State Senator, nominee for Lt. Governor, US Representative, and now Senator, Schwarz's curriculum vitae is even more impressive. He earned a Bachelor's of History from the University of Michigan, his MD from Wayne State University, and then entered the US Navy as an officer serving as a battlefield surgeon in Viet Nam. He joined the Defense Intelligence Agency and later the CIA, where he still today cannot disclose his full involvement.

He came back to Michigan and began a practice as an Otolaryngologist (ear, nose, and throat), became Mayor of Battle Creek, was then elected State Senator in 1986, and served there until 2002 as a result of state mandated term limits. He made an unsuccessful bid for Governor of Michigan that same year, and lost decidedly to eventual winner, Lt. Governor Dick Posthumous.

In 2004, Rep. Nick Smith announced he was retiring and Schwarz decided to run for his seat in southern Michigan. He won a hotly contested Republican Primary against five other Republicans, and proceeded to win the general election over Sharon Renier with about 59% of the vote.

(Before I go any further, I forgot to mention this in my original posting. What's 15 minutes between the original and an edited update? We can still be friends, eh?)

Most freshmen Congressman accomplish very little in their first two years, let alone ten years if they make it that far in politics. Rep. Schwarz, however, was able to convince the Base Realignment Commission (BRAC) to save the National Guard Base in Battle Creek, which in turned saved thousands of jobs in the region.

Unfortunately, Schwarz lost his reelection bid in the 2006 GOP Primary to Tim Walberg, a social fanatic whose campaign was funded largely by out-of-state interest groups like the Club for Growth. Walberg's little helpers ran a misinformation and smear campaign against Schwarz who was targeted as a liberal due to his moderate stances on a number of social issues, such as abortion, embryonic stem cell research, and his opposition to a state constitutional amendment banning gay marriage, because he felt the matter did not rise to the level of a constitutional question.

Schwarz has not been involved in politics since he lost his seat four years ago. In 2008, he endorsed then-State Senator Mark Schauer from Battle Creek over Walberg. Schauer defeated Walberg, as he ran on Barack Obama's coattails. Despite being the superior candidate, Schauer was defeated last Tuesday by Walberg in a reelection bid that swept over 60 Democrats out of the House of Representatives.

But I think Schwarz should run. The likelihood of a quick economic rebound in Michigan is very low at this point. The economy is tied to Obama's fortunes, as well as many incumbent Democrats like Stabenow. Schwarz's moderate views could make his candidacy appealing to independents and some conservative Democrats all over the state, including vote-rich Oakland County, a former GOP stronghold that went for Rick Snyder this last election.

Despite his lack of name recognition, Schwarz's biggest challenge might be his aversion to fund raising. He has been known to avoid "the ask" to solicit campaign contributions. But perhaps a larger GOP operation behind him could alleviate some of that aversion.

There may be a question about his age. He was first elected to the House when he was 66. In 2012, he'll turn 75 in less than two weeks after the election. But age has rarely been an impediment for US Senators. Even if he only serves one term in the Senate and retires, his expertise on so many areas including the military, foreign policy, education, and science would make him an asset to the GOP caucus in the upper chamber.

A quick scan of the internet shows some interest on facebook among GOP activists at nominating former US Representative Pete Hoekstra of Holland. But no Republican has announced his candidacy yet. I would expect that sometime in the spring of next year, we'll begin to see exploratory committees formed and official announcements made in the fall of 2011.

As of today, I don't think it'll happen. More likely, he'll continue his practice at Battle Creek, work as a visiting lecturer at U of M, and accept an appointment here and there to various state boards commissioned by Gov. Snyder.

But the Republican Party, the state, and the US Senate need more people like Dr. Schwarz. I'm not trying to carry water for Republicans - they can do that without me.

But if Joe Schwarz gives it a go, I'll actually vote in 2012.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

You are never going to get off the Joe Schwartz Koolaid?

Here is a small test of Joe Schwartz's voting record:

1) Voted NO on Private Property Rights implementation act 2006

GOP voted YES.... Dems voted NO

2) YES on Pension Protection Act 2005

GOP voted NO.... DEMs YES

3) Voted NO on implementing the United States - OMAN free trade agreement.

GOP voted YES....DEMS...NO

4) Stem Cell Research Enhancement Act - YES

GOP....NO..... DEMS....YES

5) Alternative Pluripotent Stem Cell Therapies Act - NO

GOP....YES..... DEMS....NO

6) Establishing Task Force on Ocean Policy....YES


This is who you want back in Power?

He's a hypocrite on Stem Cell Research. He favors killing Embryos which have lead to ZERO medical cures or treatments.....While saying NO to any alternative research on using Adult Stem Cells....which have indeed lead to many treatments.

He wants to create an Ocean Policy Regulatory Task Force Boondoggle not even the Democrats can support.

--Jeff MacMillan - EMU HURON Alumnus / Tea Party Member